An Investigation of Modern Physics by Brian Williams
RSS icon Home icon
  • Light Passing Through Dense Media

    Posted on October 9th, 2010 Brian 13 comments

    Part of the catechism of the physics establishment is that “Light is slowed when it passes through a dense medium.”  As an engineer I find it a refreshing change to find something with which I can agree with the physicists. However, as it is obvious that anything (freely) passing through any medium will slow down, it is not really an earth shattering ‘discovery’. Note:  Anything constrained to pass through a medium may in fact be forced to retain its original speed, or even to increase its speed. This point is of particular importance in explaining some colour phenomena.

    The important point about the statement is in its relationship to experiments carried out to verify it.

    White light passing through different lengths of ‘dense’ medium, showed different colours depending on length.

    The light exiting from the longest length of ‘dense’ medium was blue.

    The physicist’s conclusion from this fact is that only the blue light had sufficient energy to pass through the dense medium! Note: This is one of the ‘proofs’ claimed by physicists of the higher energy of blue light.

    Let us look at this conclusion. Consider 3 lengths of a ‘dense’ medium.

    Dense Media

    Dense Media

    Length No.1 (the shortest) emits only yellow light.

    Length No.2 (the mid length one) emits only red light.

    Length No.3 (the longest) emits only blue light.

    The energy of the light exiting the dense media gives Yellow as the highest and Blue as the lowest energy.

    The bottom strip is really a true (possible) spectrum. If you removed the interface colours, Orange and Purple you would be left with a perfect spectrum of White, Yellow, Red and Blue. Note:- This is only a spectrum relative to the human eye, other creatures may have different ranges.

    But according to the physicists only Blue light has the energy to pass through the longest length!

    Any engineer who proposed such a naïve conclusion would have been demoted to tea-lad, (Under supervision.). If we equate the above filters with water passing through a pipe, then the physicists conclusion would be that if water coming from the end a 10mile x 1” diameter pipe was only at low pressure then this meant that only low pressure water had the energy to travel that length of pipe!

    For those of you who (like physicists) have never had any interest in mechanics, the water pressure in your pipes depends on how far you are from the supply pumps.  If you are within a few hundred feet from the pumps your water pressure is very high, if 10 miles away , very low. This is because energy is lost due to friction and other reasons.  The same thing applies to light.

    Oddly enough, (or logically), you do not get Cyan, Green, Magenta, Mauve, etc., etc, you only get White, Yellow, Red and Blue and interface mixtures such as Pale yellow, (Between White and Yellow) Orange, (Between Yellow and Red), and Purple, (Between Red and Blue). You do not get Cyan because Cyan is a mixture of White and Blue, and in the experiment this cannot happen because of the intervening Yellow and Red bands. You do not Green because Green is a mixture of Yellow and Blue and this cannot happen because of the intervening Red band. You do not get Magenta because Magenta requires compression, a situation that I will explain later.

    In the magnificent photograph below you see an example of light passing through a dense medium. It shows a cloud layer passing over an active  volcano. [This photograph was passed to me by e-Mail, from an unknown source. Over a year I get thousand of photographs with no information on the source]

    Where the cloud layer is thinnest, bright Yellow is seen. As the cloud gets thicker, the colours go through deeper Yellow then Orange then Red then Purple. Interestingly, where the sun is shining on top of the cloud layer a dark Brown/Khaki is seen. You are seeing this by projected light from your computer. you would be seeing the photograph by reflected light. The only difference between the two is due to limitations of colour handling of your monitor and the limitations of photo printing.

     

    Author-  Brian Williams

    Volcano Cloud

    Volcano Cloud

     

    13 responses to “Light Passing Through Dense Media”

    1. jackie evancho

      People are very busy today and when you are looking for something and find it, you really want to thank the author – and this is what I am doing right now – Thanks!

    2. looraneograzy

      Completely I share your opinion. I like your idea. I suggest to take out for the general discussion.

    3. squabssobia

      What an excellent question.

    4. Anonymous

      What a great web log. I spend hours on the net reading blogs, about tons of various subjects. I have to first of all give praise to whoever created your theme and second of all to you for writing what i can only describe as an fabulous article. I honestly believe there is a skill to writing articles that only very few posses and honestly you got it. The combining of demonstrative and upper-class content is by all odds super rare with the astronomic amount of blogs on the cyberspace.

    5. clactGeatte

      When you might e-mail me with a couple of recommendations on simply how you made your weblog look this excellent, I’d be grateful.
      ————–
      That is a very difficult question. I think the main reason is that from a very early age I read a lot of books and comics. i think I was reading about about 600 library books every year from the age of 8 years until I was 16 years old. Many of these were technical books covering all types of subject. After a while you begin to recognise good writing practice and the best way of presenting knowledge. Graphics are generally very important when handling technical subjects. Good graphics can save lots of time both for yourself and the reader. As an artist (not that good) and a time served draughtsman, graphics are a natural format for me to use. As for the style of the web site, this was governed by the books, using the 3 primary colours on all the books, each book using different designs but the same colours. Another point is that advertisements destroy good posts, many being absolutely appalling. Also avoid making it sound too clever or technical, it either annoys the reader or confuses them.
      So really there is no simple answer

      Brian

    6. cadsnospaps

      I think, that is not present.
      ——————
      Please explain in more detail.
      Brian

    7. Hiser

      I was been scouring the Web for such information and i wanted to thank u for this post. BTW, just off topic, where can i get a version of this theme? – Thank you
      —————-
      See my post “Running my web-site – General Notes”

    8. Stasia Bastow

      I don’t agree with your last point.
      —————
      Why not?
      Brian

    9. In my opinion you commit an error. I can prove it. Write to me in PM, we will communicate.

    10. Your e-mail address is invalid therefore I am unable to contact you. What do you mean by “PM”? Note ; You can contact me directly at physics@nets.talktalk.net
      Brian

    11. Cristobal Dinn

      An incredibly nice blog you could have here. You really love your typing style and it’s very informative posts, I am going to go back here again!

    12. Levi Howett

      Thank you for sharing superb informations. Your web-site is very cool. I am impressed by the details that you have on this blog. It reveals how nicely you understand this subject. Bookmarked this web page, will come back for extra articles. I found simply the information I already searched all over the place and just couldn’t come across. What an ideal site.

    13. yoyonoob

      Hello , my name is Yohan and I found this forum and its members really nice!

    Leave a reply